Bud vs. Momo (NA vs. Blower)

Discussion in 'Engine & Performance Modifications' started by MotherMopar, Jul 19, 2008.

  1. MotherMopar

    MotherMopar The One, The Only... MOMO

    Messages:
    4,185
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Oct 14, 2007
    Location:
    Eastlake Proper
    If there's one thing you all can rely upon me for is honesty and integrity when it comes to me telling you all what I think. I don't know a heck of alot about the mechanics of our vehicles, but I can and do analyze performance fairly well from a layman's standpoint.

    Rick and I met up at a local construction road that's about 3/4 of a mile long. There is nearly zero traffic on this road and both sides are bordered by a 30-50 foot berm of dirt... aka: its like a road bunker with no pedestrians and no driveways and/or connecting streets what-so-ever.

    In order to gain an honest and true assessment of the Vortech blower, we took driver's skill at launching out of the equation and went from a SLOW roll and 1500 rpms in 1st gear. The weather was about 74 degrees, sunny, low humidity.

    Rick calculated the distance to be nearly a 1/3 of a mile down this one stretch, but when he's reached 110 mph, the distance covered equates to 1/4 mile.

    Rick's power mods: CAI, Zoomers, Magnaflow hiflow cats, Predator and B&G tune.

    My power mods: Zoomers, Magnaflow hiflow cats and Vortech blower.

    *Prior to my blower install, Rick's car was a little bit faster than mine.

    So, we took two runs using the above formula. On both runs, I pulled ONE car length on Rick.

    We took an additional run from about 30 mph, dumped down into gear and nailed it. Rick got the jump on me this time, and I did NOT re-gain ANY ground on Rick. We finished with him ahead by about 3/4 of a car.

    So...

    My car dynoed at 435 rwhp on a mustang dyno @ Vortech. Which roughly equates to the advertised 540 hp given a dynojet and negation of drivetrain loss. Ryan and Drew dynoed at 400 rwhp at Vortech...

    Ryan beat Rick by the same distance on the same road (1 car length).

    Of note: Once I got my car length on Rick, that position held and neither of us gained.

    My honest assessment is that I gained 115 rwhp from the blower install, over stock (went from 323 to 437 on a mustang dyno)... but in real world testing, that 115 rwhp accounted for only 1 car length in an approximate 1/4 mile race.

    Whether this is or is not an expected outcome, I have no idea.

    I am impressed with my blower, as it did make me faster; but with an additional 35 rwhp (mustang dynoed) over Ryan/Drew, I would have expected slightly better results and not 'just' to equal their performances vs. Rick.

    EDIT: Be reminded that I am a research vehicle for Vortech. I was informed that my tune was the tune to be used in the production units. I got a INSANE deal on this blower and install, so I am NOT complaining. This is an FYI for all of you out there so that you know what you're getting... a great product... but don't think you're gonna be BLOWING people's doors off JUST because you have a blower. Mind you, the canned Vortech tune is about as safe as safe gets, and a solid custom tune will really light the fire under this beast.
     
    Last edited: Jul 19, 2008
  2. Bud

    Bud GG EVO IX MR

    Messages:
    3,949
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Oct 14, 2007
    Really good writeup Jason. I'll also add as far as mods go Jason and I are both running the same tires and he does has a Vortech tuned Predator. Jason, Ryan, Drew, and John have spoken about the one (1) car length dilemma associated with the "out of the box" Vortech. IMO, for what the R&D crowd paid for the blowers they still got a pretty good deal. If "I" were to pay retail ($6000 + tax, and install), I would be less than happy with the results. As a matter of fact I'd be really pissed.
     
  3. HEMISFEAR

    HEMISFEAR Ur Friendly Canadian

    Messages:
    7,014
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Oct 12, 2007
    Location:
    Motor City, Canada
    Jason, I spoke with a well known tuner about Vortech and I can tell you their tuner is good. I forget his name now...but, he tunes VERY conservatively. You should be blowing the doors off Rick period. Even with you driving. Pm me if you're interested in a VERY GOOD tune and keep that one for the street.
     
  4. HEMISFEAR

    HEMISFEAR Ur Friendly Canadian

    Messages:
    7,014
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Oct 12, 2007
    Location:
    Motor City, Canada
    Shit man, I would stroke out. The HHP Stage II package car will plumb out smoke a lightly modded SRT8. Like, Bob Marley...giant blunt smoke lol.
     
  5. Bud

    Bud GG EVO IX MR

    Messages:
    3,949
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Oct 14, 2007
    I think Drew's the only one of the locals that I haven't heard talking about getting another tune. I hope a good tune will bring the Vortech supercharger alive. I'm really starting to wonder if a twin screw on 4-6 lbs of boost and a safe tune will be worth the money. I've yet to see any track times or dyno graphs of RDP roots blown cars running stock bottom ends running. Maybe its not wise?
     
  6. Cheatek

    Cheatek SRT once, SRT always

    Messages:
    5,628
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Nov 27, 2007
    Location:
    Nor Cal
    Jason, Rick, good write up guys, good "real world" test. I know you guys, Rick especially, are really good about being fair and covering your basis but I have a question ... were both cars as "equal" as they could be?? I'm talking about tire pressure, heat soak, full gas tank, extra weight (golf clubs in the back, lol) stuf like that?? In my experience with centrifugal blowers I might expect Jason to pull more on the top end as that kind of blower makes more and more power the higher it spins, unlike a screw type or roots type. Again, good write up guys!!
     
  7. 1bad4dr

    1bad4dr Mr. Meany

    Messages:
    19,670
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Oct 10, 2007
    Location:
    Corn Country
    Great questions Scotty.

    On the tune from Vortech, it IS conservative, VERY conservative. I believe someone had mentioned that the A/F was sitting in the upper 10's rather than the lower 11's. With time and KR to match, there is pleanty of power to be had.

    Now, on the tune, it is probably the only way that Vortech can legally offer the 3 year 36K mile warranty. IMO

    Get a nice CMR tune and unleash the power.
     
  8. Stretch

    Stretch Silver Supporting Members

    Messages:
    4,847
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Nov 6, 2007
    Location:
    Eastlake Proper
    When Ryan and I dyno'd after the Vortech, the AF was WELL below 10. It wouldn't even register on the chart because it started at 10. The guys at the Dyno Shop (actual name of the shop) said there was a LOT to be gained in the tune as everyone has said, but I agree, not very impressed with only being able to pull one to two car lengths. My car with the hi-flow cats, Zoomers and AFE pulled 402 on the dyno that I pulled 450 with after the Vortech. Botom line, 50 hp give or take is very low for a SC, even with the low boost we are running. They did say the SC's were very well designed and could easily push 700 to 800 hp if our engines could handle it with some forged items, especially rods and pistons, easily with pully changes, cams, tunes, etc. I have GOT to get a Friday off so I can get to the track and see exactly what the time and top speed differences will be now.
     
  9. HEMISFEAR

    HEMISFEAR Ur Friendly Canadian

    Messages:
    7,014
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Oct 12, 2007
    Location:
    Motor City, Canada
    This explains things more. 50 hp is a result of being very safe. Way more to be had there. I'm sure things could be different if you want them to be, but again, without forged internals...it's how 'safe' you want to run. Thanks for the reviews guys. Sounds like a good product if the leash was let out some more hehehe.
     
  10. Brad Jones

    Brad Jones New Member

    Messages:
    384
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Nov 14, 2007
    Location:
    Tampa, Florida
    I have finally managed to squirrel away $6,000.00 for some mods to my car and I am also very interested in the twin screw setup as well, but I have the same question, is it wise to run the twin screw with a stock bottome end?
     
  11. Frozen

    Frozen No innocence in glory...

    Messages:
    47
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Jun 4, 2008
    Location:
    Long Island - NY
    interesting. So not much to different then heads/cam

    im very interested in what these will do with a kick a** CMR tune
     
  12. PPPAndy

    PPPAndy New Member

    Messages:
    902
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Nov 16, 2007
    I would take it to Vortech and have them look at the tune again. Our pro-charged srt8 charger ran a 12.1@113mph bone stock with not even a catback exhaust. Against a stock charger, that would have been about 4-6 car lengths. We also had a very conservative tune in the car and dynoed 460rwhp/480rwtq. If your lean or have too much timing, you could be detonating and the pcm could be pulling allot of timing back out. You should go back to vortech or install a wideband.



    We are about 6 weeks out from releasing out whipple 2.3L twin screw system and 12 weeks out from the 2.9L whipple system. As long as your tune is good, you will be perfectly fine on the stock bottom end. Just keep the boost below 5-7psi.
     
  13. 6.1luvr

    6.1luvr Baptized by Fire

    Messages:
    971
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Nov 7, 2007
    Excellent write up!...I am very surprised also to see the results of only a car length, definitely get on the dyno with a good CMR tuner. I went from 349 hp to a 377 when dynosteve dialed me in 2 weeks ago, so you should have alot more on the table for sure with what your packing.
    Give RDP a call and see what they can do, I highly recommend Steve and Bryan, Steve will work that car until it is perfect on the dyno and on the street.
     
  14. Frozen

    Frozen No innocence in glory...

    Messages:
    47
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Jun 4, 2008
    Location:
    Long Island - NY
    err...im not totally stock, catback,CAI,diablo but i ran a 12.2 and i know 2 others that ran 11.9x and a 11.8x with only catback,CAI,diablo.

    If i paid 6g i would expect to in atleast mid 11's if not low 11's
     
  15. MotherMopar

    MotherMopar The One, The Only... MOMO

    Messages:
    4,185
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Oct 14, 2007
    Location:
    Eastlake Proper
    Actually, my gas tank was at 1/4 tank... so that's not much weight... plus, Rick weighs about 30 lbs +/- than I. We both drove the same relative distance to the road... BUT... Rick had done a few pulls before I got there. So, technically, my car was lighter and cooler than his.

    I'd have expected me to pull anytime I hit above 2800 rpms (when the boost kicks in). But, not really.

    Wow. We're R&D vehicles for Vortech, and our tunes are basically set in steel. The tune is as such because they are going for CARB legal (California emissions).

    I'm impressed with Vortech overall, the staff especially. They're very helpful, friendly folks. Their product line in general is legendary.

    HOWEVER... like a few have said... IF I was to have paid $6000+ for this blower and tune... I'd be a little upset.

    I'm gonna have to work on getting this car tuned properly for what its meant for... *there is a caveat to it, which we'll explain later once things are hashed out.
     
  16. sdcarguy

    sdcarguy A bit off

    Messages:
    790
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Nov 9, 2007
    Location:
    San Diego
    Remember Bud has a predator with a b&g tune, cats, exhaust and an intake. Plus the shifting on the vortech tune isnt very good at all. There is at least 2 tenths in just the shifting to be had I would bet. I can say that my shift second to third is so slow I can count it off...Lance has these tunes so safe because of the fact they have to warranty them. There is at least 30-50 to gain low end alone from a tune. The graphs of these cars with the vortech tune show that ricks car was making more sooner then was passed by the boost.

    Please dont judge at this point the numbers from the dynos they are not really representative of what is left in the kits. Sure they make good numbers which in comparison are better numbers then heads/cam cars but due to the fact of how the power is applied they arent responding as well. With some tuning of the cars to adjust the low end and shifting I bet you see more numbers in the 525-550 range on a non mustang dyno and that those graphs look much better. They just arent making the low end that they can due to safety.
     
  17. MotherMopar

    MotherMopar The One, The Only... MOMO

    Messages:
    4,185
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Oct 14, 2007
    Location:
    Eastlake Proper
    John, glad you stopped in and responded. Like I said above, there's ALOT to be had in the tune, that's for sure. And once that is done, then we're looking at multiple car lengths... the way it should be.
     
  18. 1bad4dr

    1bad4dr Mr. Meany

    Messages:
    19,670
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Oct 10, 2007
    Location:
    Corn Country
    Let me guess, you and the two others ran at ATCO or E-Town in the Spring when the DA was -2500?

    I have never seen or heard pf (until now) a catback, CAI, and CMR tune run that low of a time. What was your trap?

    Not doubting, but those times are not consistant with others with the same mods.
     
  19. The Max

    The Max Full Access Member

    Messages:
    184
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Jan 31, 2008
    I would have expected more than 1 to 2 car lengths, but why don't you compare to a stock vehicle? That would give you a better indication of a true HP boost from supercharger.

    This dilemma is for all modders, whether to supercharge or just build motor for HP. Mines bigger than yours attitude.

    Personally would like a 632cu. inch aluminum block motor with a supercharger. now that would be fast.The way gas prices are going, all well.

    Our SRT's are plenty fast just stock. In just a couple of seconds of WOT and I am going waaay tooo fast for regular streets.

    Life is tooo short. Just have fun with your ride.
     
  20. Bud

    Bud GG EVO IX MR

    Messages:
    3,949
    Likes Received:
    0
    Joined:
    Oct 14, 2007
    Essentially Jason and I had the EXACT same setup prior to him getting the Vortech SC (brands included). So, I think him and I racing is a good comparison of the before and after of the "out of the box" Vortech SC. Oh...and so far between Ryan, Drew, and Jason there has been NO 1-2 car lengths. It has been ONE (1) car length. LOL